Toshiba faces multi-billion dollar payout on AP1000 delays; Entergy exits merchant market

Nuclear power news you need to know.

Toshiba now estimates goodwill payments linked to Westinghouse's acquisition of S&W could reach several billion US dollars.

Related Articles

Toshiba faces billions of dollars of goodwill payments following AP1000 delays

Toshiba Corp has warned it faces goodwill payments of several billion US dollars following Westinghouse's acquisition of nuclear construction and integrated services company CB&I Stone & Webster (S&W), contractor on Westinghouse's four US AP1000 construction projects.

Westinghouse is a 100% subsidiary of Toshiba and delays to the AP1000 projects have hiked impairment estimates linked to the acquisition of S&W, Toshiba said in a statement released December 27.

Toshiba's share price plummeted on the announcement (see below chart).

Westinghouse purchased the S&W company from Chicago Bridge and Iron (BC&I) in a transaction completed in January 2016.

At that time, the goodwill for the transaction was estimated at around $87 million and the acquirer agreed to finalise the figure by the end of 2016.

In its statement, Toshiba said "the possibility has been found that the goodwill will reach a level of several 100 billion yen or several billion US dollars, resulting in a negative impact on Toshiba's financial results, as a result of impairment of all or part of the goodwill."

                                   Toshiba Corp share price

Source: Bloomberg

Westinghouse was given until the end of 2016 to evaluate the cost to complete AP1000 construction contracts in order to measure fair value of acquired assets and liabilities of the S&W transaction.

"Westinghouse has found that the cost to complete the U.S. projects will far surpass the original estimates, mainly due to increases in key project parameters," Toshiba said December 27.

Delays to the construction of Vogtle 3 & 4 and V.C. Summer 2 & 3 projects led to long-running litigation between the developers and the contractor company.

The Vogtle 3 & 4 reactors were originally scheduled to come online in 2016 and 2017, but delays have pushed back the expected start up dates to 2019 (Unit 3) and 2020 (Unit 4).

Westinghouse's acquisition of S&W made Westinghouse the sole primary contractor for the Vogtle project. The company then subcontracted Fluor group to manage the construction workforce at Vogtle, as well as the V.C. Summer 2 & 3 plant being developed by the SCE&G and Santee Cooper group in South Carolina.

Under the latest project schedule, V.C. Summer 2 is forecast to be completed by 2019 while unit 3 is expected to be completed by 2020.

Toshiba Corp said it would determine the value of the possible Westinghouse loss before it releases its full-year financial forecast.

New York Indian Point plant to close in 2020-2021

Entergy's 2 GW Indian Point nuclear plant is to close in 2020-2021 after a deal was signed between the operator and New York State officials.

Under the settlement, New York State has agreed to drop legal challenges to the plant and support the renewal of the operating licence, Entergy said January 9. The plant is situated 30 miles north of New York City and New York Governor Andrew M. Cuomo has voiced concern over safety violations at the plant given its proximity to the density-populated city.

The shutdown of Indian Point will complete Entergy’s exit from its merchant power business due to sustained low wholesale energy prices.

“Key considerations in our decision to shut down Indian Point ahead of schedule include sustained low current and projected wholesale energy prices that have reduced revenues, as well as increased operating costs,” Bill Mohl, president of Entergy Wholesale Commodities, said in a company statement.

"Record low gas prices, due primarily to supply from the Marcellus Shale formation, have driven down power prices by about 45%, or by about $36/MWh, over the last ten years, to a record low of $28/MWh. A $10/MWh drop in power prices reduces annual revenues by approximately $160 million for nuclear power plants such as Indian Point," Mohl said.

Indian Point consists of two operational reactors. Unit 2 began commercial operation in 1974 and Unit 3 in 1976.

Entergy to close Michigan nuclear plant in 2018

Entergy is to permanently close its 811 MW Palisades nuclear power plant in Michigan in October 2018 due to uneconomic market conditions, the company said in a statement December 8.

Entergy and Consumers Energy, Michigan’s largest utility, have agreed to terminate a power purchase agreement (PPA) for the entire plant capacity in 2018. The original agreement ran until April 2022 and the early termination will lower the cost to consumers "by as much as $172 million over four years," Entergy said.

"Since first entering into a PPA in 2007, when Entergy purchased Palisades from Consumers Energy, market conditions have changed substantially, and more economic alternatives are now available to provide reliable power to the region," Entergy said.

Under the current plan, Palisades will be refueled as scheduled in the spring of 2017 and operate through the end of the fuel cycle before being permanently shut down on October 1, 2018.

US pro-nuclear group says 35 GW at "triple risk" of closure

Environmental Progress, a pro-nuclear research group, has said that 35 GW of U.S. nuclear capacity is at "triple risk" of closure because the plants are in de-regulated markets, reported to be uneconomical and up for relicensing before the end of 2030.

A far larger capacity could be at risk of closure, according to the research published by Environmental Progress on December 29. Cheap natural gas, heavily-subsidized solar and wind, and flattening electricity demand, make nuclear plants less economical everywhere, not just in deregulated markets, it said.

The research group also said that 20% fewer nuclear reactors were at risk of closure than at the beginning of 2016 thanks to policies implemented by New York and Illinois governments to recognize the environmental value of nuclear energy.

               20% of at-risk nuclear capacity saved in 2016

Source: Environmental Progress

IAEA ratifies safety options for French deep waste project

The safety options of France’s Cigeo project to build and operate its first deep geological facility for the disposal of high and intermediate-level radioactive waste are "overall thorough," International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), said in a statement December 19.

As yet there are no high-level waste facilities in operation anywhere in the world and France, Finland and Sweden have made the most progress towards operating such facilities.

Cigeo is to be situated on the border between the Meuse and Haute-Marne departments in northeast France. The facility will house approximately 10,000 cubic metres of high level waste and 70,000 cubic metres of intermediate level waste.

At the request of the French Nuclear Safety Authority (ASN), the IAEA reviewed the “Safety Options File” of Cigeo via a peer review which lasted from November 7 to November 15.

The Cigeo project is being developed by the French National Radioactive Waste Agency (ANDRA). The developer is aiming to attain a licence for the facility in 2018 and operation of the facility is planned to begin in 2025.

Before ANDRA can get the authorization to create the disposal facility, it needs to demonstrate that the facility can be maintained passively once it is closed up.

Passive safety can be demonstrated by showing how the facility functions in normal and extraordinary situations, factoring in potential seismic movements and climate change.

“We requested an IAEA review mission because we wanted an independent international assessment of the safety considerations of the Cigeo project to complement our national assessment,” said Christophe Kassiotis, Head of the Waste, Research and Fuel Cycle Facilities Department at ASN.

Nuclear Energy Insider